let's talk

When Chambers and Legal 500 Referees Do Not Respond

How Chambers, Legal 500 and other directories contact referees, what they ask, when each one writes, and how to brief clients so they reply.

Pawan Khatri

Pawan Khatri

Founder

About Pawan

Published · 13 min read

Every research-led directory asks the firm to name clients who will speak about its work, and every one of them can only use the clients who answer. A practice area whose referees stay silent leaves the researcher ranking it on the submission and on what competitors say. Legal 500's template calls referee feedback "a critical part of our research". Chambers says its rankings are "based on real interviews with your specified references."

I ran my firm's Chambers and Legal 500 submissions before I started Konan & Spade, and the referee list was always the part with the least control. A partner can rewrite a narrative overnight, but nobody at the firm can make a client open an email.

This guide sets out how each directory contacts referees, what it asks them, when the emails arrive, and what a firm can do before and during each window. It sits alongside our legal directory submissions service guides.

How Chambers contacts referees

Chambers explains its referee process in its research FAQs, and the details decide when a briefing works.

Email first, from @chambers.com

Chambers says "Initial outreach is by email." The researcher then tries to set up a phone call or sends a survey for the referee to complete. A referee who does not reply may get a follow-up call or email, though Chambers says that depends on the researcher's schedule and how far the research has progressed.

The sender is usually the researcher listed on the research schedule for the practice area. If another firm has also put the referee forward for a different area, someone else on the research team may write first. For that reason Chambers suggests telling referees to look out for "an email from someone from Chambers" and adds that its emails always come from an address ending @chambers.com. Brief referees with the domain. A researcher's name can change.

Timing and the Chambers research schedule

The Chambers research schedule lists a research period for each practice area. Chambers says it aims to have contacted all referees by the end of that period, and that outreach generally starts near the beginning of the research month. A referee put forward by several firms may hear from Chambers earlier, and the researcher will still ask about your firm.

Windows can be short. Take one jurisdiction in Chambers Asia-Pacific 2027: India Tax ran from 2 to 20 February 2026, Banking & Finance from 2 to 23 February, Intellectual Property from 23 March to 24 April, Corporate/M&A from 7 April to 6 May, and Dispute Resolution and Arbitration from 18 May to 16 June. A referee who is travelling for the first fortnight of a three-week window may miss it entirely. Windows move between editions, so check each cycle.

When a window opens, the researcher usually emails the firm's submission contact to say research has started. Chambers researchers have told firms that letting referees know at that point "will improve the response rate". That email is the trigger for the second briefing described below.

What Chambers asks referees

Chambers says the conversations are open-ended, so that every firm that named the person is covered. Researchers mainly want three things:

  • the nature of the relationship between the firm and the referee
  • the type of work the firm handled for the referee in "the last year or so"
  • the referee's views on the quality of the service, including "constructive criticisms"

Researchers try to get feedback on all the firms a referee has used. A referee you name is guaranteed to be asked about your firm specifically. Chambers does not confirm which referees gave feedback.

The 3-month rule

Chambers will not contact a referee again within three months of an earlier attempt for another firm or practice area. The point, in its words, is to avoid "referee fatigue". Researchers share one central system, so whoever speaks to the referee can see the other referrals and ask about them in one conversation.

Inside one firm, the "Also Referee For (Additional Practice Areas)" column on the Chambers referee spreadsheet handles this. List a client once, add the other practice areas they can speak to, and Chambers deals with them in one contact. Repeating the client across several practice-area sheets adds no calls.

Legal 500 runs its referee research as an email survey. Its FAQs say each referee receives "Only one, plus scheduled reminders". A client named by several firms, or for several practice areas, gets one email with a link for each. Legal 500 says it emails the firm before referees are contacted, and that "typically we try to give 5 days advance notice". That notice is the moment to send your second briefing.

The scale explains why personal briefings matter. Legal 500's 2027 EMEA "Referees explained" note says it sent more than 300,000 referee emails during its 2024 research. The emails are generated automatically from the firm's spreadsheet, sent from the researcher, and go out shortly after the editorial submission deadlines.

Referees are asked for "opinions on strengths, weaknesses, innovation, individuals, and the general legal market". Answers are confidential, and Legal 500 will not copy firms on referee emails. A referee who missed the emails can use Legal 500's referee form at legal500.com/referee-form/, which firms can share. Legal 500 adds that there is "no guarantee that feedback submitted outside of the research window will be published."

For Legal 500 Asia Pacific 2027, firms received a referee contact notice on 10 July 2026, referees received "Request for Confidential Feedback" emails from 17 July, and reminders continued until mid-September. One email followed by reminders over two months gives a firm several chances to nudge, provided someone is watching the calendar.

Two Legal 500 rules affect late lists. A list filed after the deadline "may still be processed", with no promise of when. A client who has already been emailed because another firm named them will not be emailed again, so a late addition can miss the survey altogether.

Legal 500 sells its own tracking product. Its FAQs describe a "premium subscription package, which includes access to our Referee Track & Add feature". Buying it is optional, and submitting is free.

Referee contact windows by directory

Each publisher writes to referees at a different point in its cycle. The table below shows the timing each one states, with the most recent dates we have.

DirectoryWhen referees are contactedHow
Chambers and PartnersDuring the practice area's research period on the research schedule, from near the start of the research monthEmail from @chambers.com, then a call or survey
The Legal 500Shortly after the editorial deadline. Asia Pacific 2027: from 17 July 2026, reminders to mid-SeptemberOne survey email plus scheduled reminders
IFLR1000After the deadline, once the client survey launches. Firms are contacted firstSurvey of referees provided by the deadline
Benchmark Litigation (Asia-Pacific)Research interviews with firms and client referees, late September to DecemberInterviews. All submitted referees are contacted
asialaw"Usually after the firm submission deadline", sometimes sooner (10 April in 2026)Email from the jurisdiction's researcher
Managing IP (IP STARS)"Between November and March" after the October deadlineEmail from [email protected]
ITR World TaxClient Feedback Survey after the March deadline, into the summerSurvey
Lexology IndexDuring each report's research window, for example Capital Markets 2027 from 30 November 2026 to 28 January 2027Email, after the firm uploads references

Deadlines and windows move each cycle. Our directory deadlines tracker carries the live Chambers schedule and the months each other directory publishes.

Why referees go silent

Most non-response has one of four causes, and each has a different fix.

The referee never knew. The partner nominated a client without asking, or asked once in March for a survey that arrived in July. Some firms learn that a client was surveyed only when the client forwards the email. Spam filters catch the rest. Asialaw tells firms to have clients add the researcher's address to their safe senders list, and Chambers mentions "spam filters" when a referee says no email arrived.

The referee cannot be reached. A client who has unsubscribed from Chambers communications cannot be contacted, and the Referee Management Tool flags it as "Action required: Unsubscribed". A wrong address shows as "Invalid Email". On Legal 500's sheet, a street address typed into the country column or a sheet filled in capitals can stop the email from reaching anyone. Legal 500's referee note asks firms not to delete columns or use capital letters, and says personalised fields help "beat spam filters".

The referee is tired of being asked. A general counsel who instructs ten firms may be named by most of them, across several directories, in one season. Chambers and Legal 500 each combine requests inside their own research. Nothing combines them across publishers.

Nobody at the firm chased. The list went in with the submission, and no one recorded who was nominated where, for which window, or who would send the reminder.

The Chambers Referee Management Tool

Firms that buy Chambers' Profile Platform get the Referee Management Tool, which shows each submitted referee's status during research. Chambers' own FAQs set out how it works.

Each practice area and location moves through three research statuses. "To be started" means no researcher is assigned yet, and the firm can still amend or re-upload its submission and referees. "In Progress" runs from the research start date to the end date, and changes are no longer possible. "Complete" follows the end date.

Individual referees show as Pending, In Progress or Contacted, with the 3-month variants described above. When Chambers is struggling to reach someone, the tool shows "Action required" with one of three reasons:

StatusWhat it tells the firmWhat to do
Action required: UnsubscribedThe referee has opted out of Chambers emailsAsk the client whether they will opt back in, or replace them next cycle
Action required: Invalid EmailThe address on the sheet does not workConfirm the address and tell the researcher
Action required: No replyChambers has written and heard nothingCall the client and give them the researcher's details

After the research end date, statuses settle as Contacted or Unable to contact. They keep updating for 20 days if a late reply comes in, and then the section moves to the tool's Historic tab. The tool also shows a contact rate, the share of submitted referees marked Contacted.

The tool is optional, and submitting to Chambers is free. Its use is timing. A list of referees still marked "No reply" halfway through a window tells the partner which clients to call while the window is open. Firms without the tool can work from the researcher's "research has begun" email and the dates on the schedule.

Building a referee list that answers

Response starts with the list. Each directory sets its own size rules, and several tie referees to the submitted matters.

DirectoryReferee limitNotes
Chambers and PartnersSet per guide. Up to 30 per practice area in the USA, Canada, Asia-Pacific, UK (Solicitors), France, Germany and the UAE, five per barrister in the UK Bar17 fixed columns. Surname plus email or telephone for each referee
The Legal 500At least 20 per practice area, no maximum8 columns, with set name, region and practice area chosen first
IFLR1000No more than 15 per practice areaEach referee linked to a lawyer and a deal number
Benchmark LitigationNo limitAll submitted referees are contacted
asialawUp to 200 client refereesShared deadline with the forms in 2026
Lexology IndexNo limit, around 5 to 10 per practitioner suggestedPermission first, brief before research opens

Choose clients from the submitted matters

Several directories link each referee to the submitted work. Chambers' spreadsheet has a "Work Highlight Referee?" column for this, and a "Referring Lawyer(s)" column to name the lawyers the referee can speak about. IFLR1000 asks which lawyer and which deal number each referee relates to, and says "Referees that are not listed on the client referee form will not be contacted." ITR ties each referee to a matter number from the form.

Recency rules apply too. Legal 500 wants referees who have worked with the firm in the past 18 months, and IFLR1000 asks for clients who worked directly with the firm within the 18 months before submission. A client from a matter that closed two years ago may fall outside both.

Ask before you nominate

IFLR1000 asks firms to "confirm referees are happy to be contacted" before sending details. Managing IP asks firms to "obtain consent from your referees". Lexology Index asks for permission first. The ask should come from the partner who runs the relationship, because a client answers a request from someone they instruct.

Rebuild the list each cycle

Carrying last year's list forward keeps clients who did not answer last time. Before reusing a referee, check whether they responded and whether they still instruct the firm. A shorter list of clients who have agreed to answer, tied to submitted matters, gives the researcher more to work with than a long list of contacts who barely know the team. Legal 500's minimum of 20 still applies, so a thin practice may need co-counsel or referring firms, which Legal 500 and Chambers both accept as referees.

Our referee spreadsheet templates build each publisher's sheet in its own column order from one client list, which removes the re-keying errors that stop emails arriving.

Briefing referees

Two briefings work better than one. The first goes out when the partner asks for permission, and the second when the window opens. The outlines below are guidance for the partner to put in their own words.

The first briefing, at nomination

Keep it short and specific:

  • which directory or directories, and which practice area
  • the matter or matters they can speak to, by name
  • roughly when the email will arrive, taken from the research schedule or the directory's published timing
  • the sender to look for, for example an address ending @chambers.com or [email protected]
  • a request to add that address to their safe senders list
  • a request for candid feedback, including anything the firm could have done better

Chambers asks referees for "constructive criticisms", and Legal 500 asks about weaknesses as well as strengths. A referee told to give "positive feedback" is being asked for something neither directory wants, and the answers tend to read as scripted praise.

The second briefing, when the window opens

Send it when the Chambers researcher confirms research has started, or when Legal 500's notice arrives about five days before its survey goes out. Two or three lines are enough. Say the email is on its way or has arrived, name the sender, explain that it takes a short call or a survey, and thank them. For Legal 500, a further nudge during the reminder period helps referees who set the first email aside.

Spread the load

A client named by several directories in one season hears from each of them. Keep a register of who was nominated where, and agree with the partner which two or three directories matter most for each client. Within Chambers, use "Also Referee For". Within Legal 500, one email covers every firm and practice area that named the client.

When a referee says the email never arrived

Chambers' advice for a referee showing "No reply" who says nothing arrived is to share the researcher's email address and ask the referee to write directly. The researcher's contact details are on the research schedule, under any practice area marked "Researching". Chambers notes that after several unanswered emails, another one is unlikely to get a reply.

That is the only case where Chambers wants the referee to make contact. Otherwise it discourages firms from asking referees to reach out, because it can affect "the reliability of the feedback provided", and says unsolicited feedback may be "scrutinised and possibly discounted". For Legal 500, the public referee form covers a client who missed the survey.

After the window closes

Chambers will not tell the firm which referees gave feedback, and Legal 500 keeps responses confidential. What the firm can learn is who was reached. Record the final Referee Management Tool status for each referee, or ask partners which clients mentioned a call, and carry that into next year's list. A practice area where few referees were reached is the first thing to check if a ranking slips, which our post on why a law firm's directory ranking dropped covers.

Partners also receive requests from the other side. Chambers contacts a firm's own partners as peer referees for other firms, under the heading "Request for Feedback", and asialaw sends nominated leading lawyers its Lawyer Survey. Answering takes partner time in the months the firm is busy with its own submissions.

Other directories treat silence differently. Managing IP warns that firms "may lose ratings score" without client referees. ITR says "We do not penalize firms for not providing referees" but adds that positive client feedback improves a firm's chances. Legal 500's referee note says a firm "will not be excluded from a ranking" for providing none, while calling feedback "an important element" of the research. Asialaw says a missed researcher interview "will not affect your practice area's rating".

For the Chambers form itself, see our Chambers and Partners submissions page, and for the partner call that often runs alongside referee research, our guide to preparing for a Chambers research interview.

Frequently Asked Questions

How does Chambers contact referees?

By email first, from an address ending @chambers.com. The researcher then tries to arrange a call or sends a survey, and may follow up by phone or email if time allows. Outreach usually starts near the beginning of the research month shown on the Chambers research schedule.

What does Chambers ask referees?

The conversation is open-ended. Chambers says researchers mainly want the nature of the relationship, the work the firm did for the referee in the last year or so, and the referee's view of the service, including constructive criticism.

How many referees does Legal 500 want?

Legal 500 asks for at least 20 referees per practice area and sets no maximum. Its guidelines say it will contact all referees submitted on time. Referees should have worked with the firm in the past 18 months.

What does "3-month ruling" mean in the Referee Management Tool?

Chambers will not contact a referee again within three months. If the referee was already emailed for another firm or practice area, the tool shows "In Progress: 3-month ruling". If they have already been in touch, it shows "Contacted: 3-month ruling".

Can our referee email the Chambers researcher directly?

Chambers discourages it because it can affect the reliability of the feedback, and says unsolicited feedback may be scrutinised and possibly discounted. The exception is a referee who cannot receive Chambers emails. Then the firm can share the researcher's address from the research schedule.

Do other directories penalise referee non-response?

Practice differs. Managing IP warns that firms may lose ratings score without client referees. ITR says it does not penalise firms for providing none but that positive client feedback helps. Legal 500 says a firm will not be excluded from a ranking for providing no referees.

Case studies

Services that we provide

Book a free 30-minute directory strategy call

Book a strategy call

We will look at where you rank today, which directories are worth your effort this cycle, and what a realistic submission plan looks like for your practice areas.

Konan & Spade revolutionized our digital presence. Their expertise in law firm marketing is unmatched, the website, SEO, everything they deliver is top-tier.
Ajmal NadakkalManaging PartnerABS Partners, UAE

Work with us

Monthly retainers start at

$2,000 / month

Our process:

  1. Schedule a discovery call

    A 30-minute deep dive into your past marketing, your competitors and where you actually want to be cited.

  2. Receive your growth plan

    A tailored strategy naming the right channels, the priorities, and a clear roadmap to get there.

  3. Start getting found

    We hold a kickoff call, implement the plan, and start moving visibility inside the first 30 days.

No decks, no discovery theatre

Tell us where you want to be found

Tell us what you need

Let's talk

Send us the shape of the problem and we will reply within one working day.

Prefer email? [email protected]

let's talk