Confidential Matters in Legal Directory Submissions
How Chambers, Legal 500, IFLR1000, Benchmark and others treat confidential matters, how each template wants them marked, and where details leak.
Every directory asks for your best work, and some of your best work is under a confidentiality obligation. Each publisher has a way to accept it without printing it, and each marks it differently. Chambers uses a separate section and Legal 500 a separate box, while the rest use red ink, a Yes/No field or a button in an online form. Mark a matter the wrong way for the template in front of you and the publisher may treat it as publishable.
This post goes through how the main directories handle confidential matters and clients, what confidentiality costs a submission, and where firms let details slip. It quotes each publisher's 2026 or 2027 template, guidelines and FAQs. The form-by-form detail sits on our legal directory submissions service pages.
What marking a matter confidential does
Every publisher we cover reads confidential work and uses it to rank. Chambers says: "Any information marked 'Confidential' will not be disclosed in any way. We appreciate you sending it, however, since it is useful in determining your ranking." Benchmark Litigation's Europe FAQ says it "will only use this information for internal understanding and analysis purposes". Legal 500 describes its research as built partly on details of work "some of which will be confidential and not in the public domain".
Confidentiality also has a cost. Chambers explains that the publishable section "will tell our researchers that they can write about this work highlight when creating any commentary about your firm once the rankings are launched". A department that files all 20 matters as confidential gives the researcher nothing to cite in the editorial. Legal 500's guidelines ask for "At least one matter" cleared for publication. IFLR1000's form says "You may include confidential deals, but we recommend that you include some publishable work", and adds that publishable deals which closed in the research year "will be given more weight".
So the aim is a mix. Confidential matters carry the evidence a researcher needs to rank the department, and publishable matters give the editorial something to say.
How each directory marks confidential work
| Directory | How confidential work is marked | Default for unmarked text |
|---|---|---|
| Chambers and Partners | Separate sections: D (publishable, green) and E (confidential, red), with D0 and E0 client lists | Section D "is considered PUBLISHABLE" |
| The Legal 500 | Non-publishable matter boxes and client list, plus "CONFIDENTIAL, in bold red and upper case" elsewhere | Information "may be published" unless marked |
| IFLR1000 | Y/N confidentiality question per deal, with the details in red | "Treated as non-confidential unless it is clearly marked in red" |
| Benchmark Litigation | Yes / No / Partially per case, with the details in red | "Any information given may be published except where indicated in RED" |
| asialaw | Red text, opened and closed with the word "Confidential" | "Anything not marked accordingly may be published without notice" |
| ITR World Tax | "Is ANY part of this matter confidential?" plus red text | "Treated as publishable" |
| Managing IP (IP STARS) | Confidential (Yes or No) per case study, and "(Confidential)" written beside the text | "May be published" |
| Lexology Index | Buttons to mark a whole highlight or only its value | Non-confidential details may appear in editorial |
Chambers: Sections D and E
The Chambers form has two matter sections, and their preambles leave no room for interpretation. Section D: "All information in section 'D' is considered PUBLISHABLE. Do not include any confidential information in this section." Section E: "All information in section 'E' is considered CONFIDENTIAL and NOT FOR PUBLICATION. Information in this section will only be used for our internal ranking purposes." Chambers' submissions page describes the template's "clear colour coding to indicate sensitive material that must be handled with extra care", and its specialist-guide page names the colours: "a green section for publishable matters and a red section for confidential matters".
Because section D is publishable in full, a matter with any confidential element belongs in section E. You cannot leave a deal in section D and mark only its value as private. The template lays out 10 matters in each section, and that layout is a default. Chambers counts up to 20 in total, divided "in any proportion", and its specialist-guide page goes further: "If you cannot include any publishable client names or work highlights, please feel free to delete the publishable section and add extra pages to the confidential section."
Clients split by section too. D0 is the publishable client list, and its content "may be printed in Chambers and Partners publications", so list a client there only once it has cleared publication. E0 holds every other client and still counts for research. Both lists ask whether each client is new in the last 12 months, which is how researchers see growth.
The fields themselves change meaning between sections. In D1, "If you cannot reveal the client name, give a general description." In E1 the client name is "for ranking purposes only", so the name goes in. The form opens with a rule that applies across all of it: "If something is confidential, mark it as such throughout." A client named in E0 should not reappear by name in the B10 narrative, in a section D matter or in a lawyer's B9 comments.
Legal 500: Boxes, red capitals and the published summary
Legal 500's template has a publishable matter box and a non-publishable one, copied as many times as needed up to 20 matters. The non-publishable box says "Matter summary" where the publishable one says "Matter description", and asks for "Jurisdictions involved" in the plural. Researchers read those matters for ranking purposes, and the guidelines ask firms to "identify the client" in every matter.
Outside the boxes, the 2027 guidelines set a stricter rule than most firms expect. "All information provided to us may be published by all Legal 500 and Legalease Ltd products, unless it is marked as confidential." Confidential details "whether client names, deal or case values, or other details" should be marked "CONFIDENTIAL, in bold red and upper case", and the guidelines ask firms to "use red typeface for all of the confidential information". That paragraph ends: "You do not need to write in red in the confidential matter boxes."
Two more instructions in that paragraph are worth printing for every partner who drafts a matter. "Please avoid putting global confidentiality restrictions at the front of submissions." A cover note saying "this whole document is confidential" protects nothing specific. The guidelines also ask firms to be "as clear as possible about what exactly is confidential", and to say whether that is "the case as a whole, the name of the client, or the issue/value at stake".
The publishing risk sits in the "Publishable matter summary": up to three matters Legal 500 prints next to the editorial for ranked firms. The form asks you to "only provide matter summaries for matters you are content for us to publish". Legal 500's client lists also come in two. The publishable list "will be published in full". The non-publishable list "will not be published".
The Legal Benchmarking Group forms: Red ink
IFLR1000, Benchmark Litigation, asialaw, ITR World Tax and Managing IP's IP STARS share one publisher, Legal Benchmarking Group, and most of their forms ask for confidential information in red within the matter itself.
IFLR1000 sets the default plainly: "All information submitted on this form will be treated as non-confidential unless it is clearly marked in red." Each deal also carries the question "Is any aspect of this deal confidential Y/N? Please mark any confidential information in RED." IFLR's awards entries feed its rankings research, and an awards entry needs its key parties and its innovation to be publishable before it can be shortlisted.
Benchmark's case table has a "Confidential? Yes / No / Partially" field with the instruction "IF YES OR PARTIAL, MARK IN RED INK BELOW!" Its Asia-Pacific methodology page says: "If there is any confidential element to a matter, it will not be published." Its awards template is stricter about the field: "if even only the client name or value is confidential, please write 'Yes'". Benchmark also says "Only public cases can be considered for the Impact Cases of the Year category", so a confidential case cannot go forward for it.
asialaw's FAQ gives the most precise instruction of the group. "If you would like us not to include the client's name, then please highlight in RED", and for longer passages, "begin and end the non-publishable part with the word 'Confidential' with font colour in RED". Its warning is blunt: "Anything not marked accordingly may be published without notice." Both asialaw and Benchmark let you describe a confidential client by its business, and their templates give "a global technology giant" as the example.
ITR asks "Is ANY part of this matter confidential?" at the top of each matter, and reminds firms that "Any information not marked as such will be treated as publishable and may appear in our publications." Clients who have not cleared publication go in red in the overview's client list as well as in the matters.
IP STARS uses a Confidential (Yes or No) field on each case study, and its submission guidelines ask you to "write '(Confidential)' next to any information that you do not want us to publish". The guidelines add two lines firms tend to miss. Any client name or work description left unmarked "may be published", and "any information in the public domain may be published." A matter already reported in the press is publishable whatever the form says. IP STARS also says that naming clients who are not marked confidential "enhances your firm's credibility in the eyes of the researcher".
Lexology Index and ALB
Lexology Index's online Work Highlights survey has buttons to mark a whole highlight, or only its value, as confidential. Non-confidential details may appear in editorial. The survey saves nothing until you press "Complete", and there is no confirmation email, so keep a screenshot of the confirmation page as your record of what you marked.
Asian Legal Business forms are Word documents, and their layout varies by list. The M&A rankings form carries a "Confidential?" field for each matter, and the other lists ask firms to mark confidential matters clearly in the form itself. Put the marking in the form text itself. A note in a reviewer comment beside the matter will not be read as a marking.
How much to say in a confidential matter
A confidential matter still has to convince a researcher, and the researcher tests it with referees. Write it with the client's name, the real value, the other firms and their roles, the lead partner and the outcome. Chambers' D2 prompt applies to section E as much as D: "Please say why this matter was important. Also, tell us exactly what role your department played."
Over-anonymising costs rankings. Our Legal 500 playbook lists, as a pitfall, anonymising "so heavily that the researcher cannot judge significance". A matter described as "a large transaction for a multinational client" tells the researcher nothing it can test, and nothing it can compare with the matters other firms sent.
Link confidential matters to referees where you can. Chambers' "Work Highlight Referee?" column ties a referee to a submitted matter, and its research FAQ says researchers want to establish "The type of work that the firm has handled for the referee in the last year or so". A client who instructed on a confidential matter is often the best person to describe it, and Chambers keeps that conversation private: "the content and matters discussed during feedback is kept private between the Chambers research team and the individual participant."
Referees, client lists and confidentiality
Referee lists are confidential by default at every publisher we cover. Chambers says: "We don't disclose the identity of our interviewees and any quotes we publish are always fully anonymised." Legal 500's template says client names on the referee sheet are held "in strict confidence" and used for nothing other than Legal 500 research. Benchmark's methodology page says "All client information provided will be treated as confidential", and IP STARS says client names in referee documents "will not be published".
Referees also control their own participation. Chambers will not tell a firm which referees responded, and says a referee may "confidentially opt out of participating in our research or opt out of providing feedback on specific firms or topics without this being shared or reported back to the firm". Ask the client before you nominate them. Chambers' specialist-guide page says so directly: "Please get permission from your references before including them on the form."
Access to the files is restricted too. Chambers says only users with "a verified Chambers MyAccount login can access and edit submissions". Legal 500 accepts files only through its portal, holds them in a secure internal system and says its staff "cannot copy, print, or email any Submissions". Neither accepts submissions by email. Legal 500 says emailed submissions "will be regarded as a security risk and not be processed".
Where confidential details leak
These are the leaks we check for, and most of them appear in our playbooks for several publishers:
- Confidential details inside a publishable matter, typically a value or a counterparty dropped into a Chambers section D summary or a Legal 500 publishable box.
- A client on a publishable list who has not agreed to be named.
- The three-matter Legal 500 publishable summary filled with a matter the client never cleared.
- A confidential client named in the narrative, a lawyer's supporting information or another practice area's form.
- Tracked changes, comments or internal notes left in the uploaded Word file. Anyone who opens the document can read them.
- A client name spelled differently across the client list, the matters and the referee sheet, which suggests two different clients.
- Red text turned black when a partner pasted the matter into a fresh copy of the template.
- A matter marked confidential on one directory's form and left unmarked on another's, when both cover one deal.
The last two need a check at the end of drafting. Red text is the only marker on the Legal Benchmarking Group forms, and it disappears in a plain-text paste.
A clearance routine
- List every matter the department may use this season, across every directory, in one register.
- Ask each client once, before drafting, whether the matter can be named and in which publication. Record the answer per matter and per directory, because a client may agree to appear in Chambers' D0 list and refuse a Legal 500 summary.
- Draft confidential matters in full, with names and values, and mark them in the way each template expects. That means section E, the non-publishable box, red ink, the Yes/No field or the button.
- Fill the Legal 500 publishable summary and any awards entries only from cleared matters.
- Before upload, accept or reject all tracked changes, delete comments, and check that every red passage is still red.
- Read the final file as the publisher will, from top to bottom, looking for confidential names outside the confidential sections.
Our pages on Chambers and Partners submissions, Legal 500 submissions and Benchmark Litigation submissions show each form's matter fields in full. The submission readiness scorecard checks a draft for the gaps above before it goes in.
Subscribe for Legal Marketing Insights
Stay ahead with proven strategies, case studies and AI-driven tactics.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do confidential matters count towards a Chambers or Legal 500 ranking?
Yes. Chambers says confidential information "will not be disclosed in any way" and that it is "useful in determining your ranking". Legal 500 reads non-publishable matters for ranking purposes. Both count them within the 20-matter limit, and Chambers lets you split the 20 between publishable and confidential "in any proportion".
Should we anonymise the client in a confidential matter?
Usually not. Chambers asks for the client name in E1 "for ranking purposes only", and Legal 500's guidelines ask firms to "identify the client". A matter described as "a large transaction for a multinational client" gives the researcher nothing to test with referees.
How do we mark confidential information in a Legal 500 submission?
Use the non-publishable matter box and the non-publishable client list for whole items. Anywhere else, Legal 500's guidelines ask you to mark the information "CONFIDENTIAL, in bold red and upper case" and to "use red typeface for all of the confidential information". You do not need red text inside the confidential matter boxes.
What if only the deal value is confidential?
It depends on the directory. Lexology Index lets you mark only the value as confidential, and Legal 500 asks you to say exactly what is confidential, whether "the case as a whole, the name of the client, or the issue/value at stake". Chambers' section D is publishable in full, so a matter with a confidential value belongs in section E. The Legal Benchmarking Group forms (IFLR1000, Benchmark Litigation, asialaw, ITR) expect the confidential text itself in red.
Can a confidential matter win an award?
Often it cannot. Benchmark Litigation says "Only public cases can be considered for the Impact Cases of the Year category", and IFLR's awards need the key parties and the innovation to be publishable before an entry can be shortlisted. Choose award entries from cleared work.
Are referees' names published?
No publisher we cover prints them. Chambers says it does not disclose the identity of its interviewees and anonymises any quotes, Legal 500 holds referee client names "in strict confidence", and Managing IP says client names in referee documents "will not be published".
Case studies

Luthra and Luthra: A New Website For A Top-Tier Indian Law Firm, Moved Without Losing Its Archive
Full-service Indian law firm with offices in New Delhi, Mumbai, Bengaluru and Hyderabad.

Cohen Murison Law: A New Website For A Toronto Immigration And Injury Lawyer
Toronto law practice for immigration, personal injury and disability claims.

TLH Advocates & Solicitors: SEO And GEO That Put Its Insights To Work
Full-service law firm headquartered in Hyderabad.

A New Name, Website And SEO For Vardharma Law
Delhi law firm advising on corporate transactions, disputes and arbitration.
